Several matching dynamic_templates?

Joel_Abrahamsson · July 31, 2011, 2:16pm

Is it possible to somehow configure dynamic_templates so that multiple
matching templates will be applied? It seems to me that only the first
matching template is used. I can see why that is, but if there's a
workaround I'd love to know about it

As an example, I'm using something like the dynamic templates below
and would like strings to be mapped both as multifield and as not
included in all IF their names end with "!inall".

{
"string_template":{
"match":"",
"match_mapping_type":"string",
"mapping":{
"type":"multi_field",
"fields":{
"{name}":{
"type":"string",
"index":"not_analyzed"
},
"standard":{
"type":"string"
}
}
}
}
},
{
"not_in_all_template":{
"match":"!inall",
"mapping":{
"include_in_all":false
}
}
},

Matthew_A_Brown · July 31, 2011, 2:23pm

Hi Joel,

Multiple matching templates are supported by ES (see the end of
Elasticsearch Platform — Find real-time answers at scale | Elastic).
It looks like you don't have a parallel structure between your two
mappings, though -- did you intend to put the 'include_in_all' key
inside a field definition?

Mat

On Sun, Jul 31, 2011 at 10:16, Joel Abrahamsson
mail@joelabrahamsson.com wrote:

Is it possible to somehow configure dynamic_templates so that multiple
matching templates will be applied? It seems to me that only the first
matching template is used. I can see why that is, but if there's a
workaround I'd love to know about it

As an example, I'm using something like the dynamic templates below
and would like strings to be mapped both as multifield and as not
included in all IF their names end with "!inall".

{
"string_template":{
"match":"",
"match_mapping_type":"string",
"mapping":{
"type":"multi_field",
"fields":{
"{name}":{
"type":"string",
"index":"not_analyzed"
},
"standard":{
"type":"string"
}
}
}
}
},
{
"not_in_all_template":{
"match":"!inall",
"mapping":{
"include_in_all":false
}
}
},

Joel_Abrahamsson · July 31, 2011, 2:58pm

Hey!

Thanks for the reply!

I'm not sure what you mean by parallel structure? The last template is
applied if I remove the first, otherwise the first but not the second
is applied.

I should probably add that I'm using these for the default type in a
default-mapping.json file.

/Joel

On 31 Juli, 16:23, "Matthew A. Brown" mat.a.br...@gmail.com wrote:

Hi Joel,

Multiple matching templates are supported by ES (see the end ofhttp://www.elasticsearch.org/guide/reference/api/admin-indices-templa...).
It looks like you don't have a parallel structure between your two
mappings, though -- did you intend to put the 'include_in_all' key
inside a field definition?

Mat

On Sun, Jul 31, 2011 at 10:16, Joel Abrahamsson

m...@joelabrahamsson.com wrote:

Is it possible to somehow configure dynamic_templates so that multiple
matching templates will be applied? It seems to me that only the first
matching template is used. I can see why that is, but if there's a
workaround I'd love to know about it

As an example, I'm using something like the dynamic templates below
and would like strings to be mapped both as multifield and as not
included in all IF their names end with "!inall".

{
"string_template":{
"match":"",
"match_mapping_type":"string",
"mapping":{
"type":"multi_field",
"fields":{
"{name}":{
"type":"string",
"index":"not_analyzed"
},
"standard":{
"type":"string"
}
}
}
}
},
{
"not_in_all_template":{
"match":"!inall",
"mapping":{
"include_in_all":false
}
}
},

Joel_Abrahamsson · July 31, 2011, 3:00pm

Oh, actually it seems we we're talking about different things. I'm not
talking about index templates by dynamic templates for types/
properties

On 31 Juli, 16:23, "Matthew A. Brown" mat.a.br...@gmail.com wrote:

Hi Joel,

Multiple matching templates are supported by ES (see the end ofhttp://www.elasticsearch.org/guide/reference/api/admin-indices-templa...).
It looks like you don't have a parallel structure between your two
mappings, though -- did you intend to put the 'include_in_all' key
inside a field definition?

Mat

On Sun, Jul 31, 2011 at 10:16, Joel Abrahamsson

m...@joelabrahamsson.com wrote:

Is it possible to somehow configure dynamic_templates so that multiple
matching templates will be applied? It seems to me that only the first
matching template is used. I can see why that is, but if there's a
workaround I'd love to know about it

As an example, I'm using something like the dynamic templates below
and would like strings to be mapped both as multifield and as not
included in all IF their names end with "!inall".

{
"string_template":{
"match":"",
"match_mapping_type":"string",
"mapping":{
"type":"multi_field",
"fields":{
"{name}":{
"type":"string",
"index":"not_analyzed"
},
"standard":{
"type":"string"
}
}
}
}
},
{
"not_in_all_template":{
"match":"!inall",
"mapping":{
"include_in_all":false
}
}
},

kimchy · July 31, 2011, 3:04pm

There isn't support in dynamic templates to "aggregate templates", the first
one matches (ordered) will be used, so you need to provide full mapping on
relevant ones. Its a bit tricky (at least in the way its implemented
currently) to apply everything the matches to the new field mapping
introduced.

On Sun, Jul 31, 2011 at 6:00 PM, Joel Abrahamsson
mail@joelabrahamsson.comwrote:

Oh, actually it seems we we're talking about different things. I'm not
talking about index templates by dynamic templates for types/
properties

On 31 Juli, 16:23, "Matthew A. Brown" mat.a.br...@gmail.com wrote:

Hi Joel,

Multiple matching templates are supported by ES (see the end ofhttp://
Elasticsearch Platform — Find real-time answers at scale | Elastic...).
It looks like you don't have a parallel structure between your two
mappings, though -- did you intend to put the 'include_in_all' key
inside a field definition?

Mat

On Sun, Jul 31, 2011 at 10:16, Joel Abrahamsson

m...@joelabrahamsson.com wrote:

Is it possible to somehow configure dynamic_templates so that multiple
matching templates will be applied? It seems to me that only the first
matching template is used. I can see why that is, but if there's a
workaround I'd love to know about it

As an example, I'm using something like the dynamic templates below
and would like strings to be mapped both as multifield and as not
included in all IF their names end with "!inall".

{
"string_template":{
"match":"",
"match_mapping_type":"string",
"mapping":{
"type":"multi_field",
"fields":{
"{name}":{
"type":"string",
"index":"not_analyzed"
},
"standard":{
"type":"string"
}
}
}
}
},
{
"not_in_all_template":{
"match":"!inall",
"mapping":{
"include_in_all":false
}
}
},

Joel_Abrahamsson · July 31, 2011, 3:09pm

I see, thanks!

2011/7/31 Shay Banon kimchy@gmail.com

There isn't support in dynamic templates to "aggregate templates", the
first one matches (ordered) will be used, so you need to provide full
mapping on relevant ones. Its a bit tricky (at least in the way its
implemented currently) to apply everything the matches to the new field
mapping introduced.

On Sun, Jul 31, 2011 at 6:00 PM, Joel Abrahamsson <
mail@joelabrahamsson.com> wrote:

Oh, actually it seems we we're talking about different things. I'm not
talking about index templates by dynamic templates for types/
properties

On 31 Juli, 16:23, "Matthew A. Brown" mat.a.br...@gmail.com wrote:

Hi Joel,

Multiple matching templates are supported by ES (see the end ofhttp://
Elasticsearch Platform — Find real-time answers at scale | Elastic...).
It looks like you don't have a parallel structure between your two
mappings, though -- did you intend to put the 'include_in_all' key
inside a field definition?

Mat

On Sun, Jul 31, 2011 at 10:16, Joel Abrahamsson

m...@joelabrahamsson.com wrote:

Is it possible to somehow configure dynamic_templates so that multiple
matching templates will be applied? It seems to me that only the first
matching template is used. I can see why that is, but if there's a
workaround I'd love to know about it

As an example, I'm using something like the dynamic templates below
and would like strings to be mapped both as multifield and as not
included in all IF their names end with "!inall".

{
"string_template":{
"match":"",
"match_mapping_type":"string",
"mapping":{
"type":"multi_field",
"fields":{
"{name}":{
"type":"string",
"index":"not_analyzed"
},
"standard":{
"type":"string"
}
}
}
}
},
{
"not_in_all_template":{
"match":"!inall",
"mapping":{
"include_in_all":false
}
}
},

Topic		Replies	Views
Multi dynamic templates - issue Elasticsearch	1	368	May 14, 2020
Defining mutiple types for match_mapping_type Elasticsearch	1	504	July 6, 2017
ES 6.1 dynamic template with multiple match_mapping_type Elasticsearch	2	1733	February 1, 2018
Issue with Dynamic Template Elasticsearch	3	466	May 26, 2017
Dynamic templates - Why is this configuration not working? Elasticsearch	2	3109	July 6, 2017

Several matching dynamic_templates?

Related topics